Your Island Vacation Home

McGreevy Cottage – Your Vacation Rental Awaits

Your Mackinac Island Family Getaway

Staying at McGreevy Cottage

The cottage is fully furnished, located in downtown Mackinac Island on historic Market Street.

Mackinac Island

Explore historic forts, one-of-a-kind golf courses, horse-drawn carriage tours, world-famous fudge, and leisurely bicycle rides along the lakeshore.


The home has a maximum capacity of six people and includes three bedrooms with an additional queen sleeper sofa.


Come and Relax

From the McGreevy Cottage Guest Book

"Thank you again, Stephanie & Andy, for another glorious time in McGreevy Cottage! ...Everything was perfect as always. Thank you for your work and care! See you next year!"

"We had a wonderful week in your lovely island Home. Mackinac Island is a magical place and we are grateful for such a comfortable place to enjoy it. It was our 2nd year in your special home and we look forward to returning next year."
M & J

"With 4 kids and 2 adults we needed a place we could stretch out for the week. Your cottage was the perfect place for us to do this. You covered every detail to make our stay extremely comfortable and all of us happy. I hope to come back and stay again! We will be sure to tell our family and friends how wonderful it is at the McGreevy Cottage and encourage them to make a reservation."
A & S

"We thoroughly enjoyed our week in your beautiful home! Great location, quiet, comfortable and close to downtown. You have done a great job providing all the comforts of home while maintaining the history of your family’s commitment and dedication to Mackinac Island. We look forward to returning again next year."

"Three generations of our family enjoyed three days on the island hiking, eating, playing relaxing and taking advantage of all the cottage has to offer. The boys enjoyed the toys and books, the grown-ups enjoyed happy hour on the deck and grilling on the Weber. Mostly great weather and a wonderful time."

"The grade for the stay was an A+. We couldn't have improved upon our time at all. We went all out and had a private carriage ride from our door, biked the island, beheld the butterflies and shopped enough (if that's possible). The cottage was the icing and cherry on our birthday cake. It met all our needs and was so comfortable for all. So happy to have found you and will certainly recommend this impeccable retreat to all."
Guests from Las Vegas, NV

"Our second stay at your cottage was even better than the first. Thank you for providing the perfect setting for another perfect family vacation."
Guests from Indianapolis, IN

"This was our second stay at the McGreevy Cottage. We absolutely love the accommodations and location of the cottage. Thank you so much for letting us enjoy the island for the week of biking, shopping and horseback riding. We look forward to staying again next year."

"We feel so lucky to have found your cottage! It made our first trip to Mackinac Island truly wonderful to have the perfect place to stay. We had a home away from home for the week. The memories are great of beautiful walks, a carriage ride and spectacular scenery. And our 3-year-old son/grandson loved watching all the horses go by while playing in the yard. Thanks again."

"We enjoyed our beautiful week at McGreevy Cottage in a way we never could have in separate hotel rooms. We had a relaxing, fun time. We loved the outside porches, the toys for the young ones, the dining table for meals, cards and talk. It was nice to have the extras available, too, like the laundry and soap, movies, blankets, dishes, pots and pans. We especially enjoyed our time together in such a nice place! We hope we can return."

"Dear Stephanie and Andy,
Another wonderfully relaxed stay in your cottage. We love the new mattress, carpeting and bed covers plus more TV channels and Wi-Fi. This is the perfect place to either veg out or be very active on bike and walking trails. We succeed in doing all of it. With the earthquake and the hurricane on the East Coast before we came, we needed some R&R in a lovely home not our own. We will be back next year!"
Guests from Chestertown, MD

"McGreevy Cottage is perfect in every way. All of our needs were met and then some. I know we will always remember this vacation and if the opportunity to come back to Mackinac Island ever happens again, I know McGreevy Cottage will be our first choice to stay in. Thank you!"

Thank you for an amazing week on the island! Our last family vacation here was 12 years ago, and everything was exactly the way we remembered. Your cottage is so welcoming and comfortable - the pertect home away from home. A wonderful place to relax from the day's adventures and watch the world go by on Market st. Hoping to return again soon!

The S ’s - Indiana
June 2023

Stephanie + Andy,
Thank you so much , we had a perfect time island in the cottage. Looks like it is going to be a new tradition.

The G family, Michigan

June 2023

Stephanie & Andy,

We have so enjoyed our week on the island. McGreevy Cottage is in the perfect Location, so welcoming, so comfortable  and IMMACULATE ! You are such gracious hosts. Alter a day of exploring the Island we saw Andy and told him how much we were enjoying his home. He said, "oh no, this is your home this week". So thoughtful & kind!

Amazing stay on the island, we look forward to seeing you next year!

M&T, Wisconsin
September 2023